Why im eating my words on veganism again george monbiot. Searching for enchantment on the frontiers of rewilding 20 and out of the. He then subjects their case to the first treatment ive read that is both objective and forensic. By george monbiot, published on the guardians website 27th. Monbiot criticises anarchism and marxism, arguing that any possible solution to the worlds inequalities must be rooted in a democratic parliamentary system. By george monbiot, published on the guardians website 27 th november 20. Then, after reading simon fairlies argument supporting the consumption of meat from animals pastured on nonarable land, monbiot backtracked and lapsed into meateating ways. Simon fairlie has updated the figures produced 30 years ago in kenneth mellanbys book can britain feed itself. Simon fairlie pays handsome tribute to vegans for opening up the debate2. The book has 250 double column pages, and 14 illustrations.
Clearly its a work of some import and is extremely persuasive. Sep 15, 2010 the british ecojournalist, george monbiot, was an enthusiastic advocate for the vegan diet. He writes a weekly column for the guardian, and is the author of a number of books, including captive state. Fairlie pointed out that around half the current global meat supply causes no loss to human nutrition. Agricultural campaigner simon fairlies explosive book, meat, proposed that a lowmeat diet can be a sustainable, ecological choice. It is edited and mostly written by simon fairlie, with chapters by simon ruston travellers, erica thompson wales and cathy ashley scotland. Equally, coming back around to this idea of eating meat as not necessarily being an inherently negative thing, simon fairlies meat. In this powerful and positive talk for the gaia foundation, george monbiot brings to life his new book, out of the wreckage a new politics for an age of crisis. Sep 16, 2018 we dont think it is, because we want to a help reduce the overall amount of meat eaten, and b help people to make a living from smallholding, which becomes a lot more difficult although not impossible without animals. The book is an attempt to set out a positive manifesto for change for the global justice movement.
Dec 20, 2017 on 29th november george monbiot visited us here on broad street and we talked about his latest book out of the wreckage. Fairlie is a powerhouse thinker, a fire hose of ideas, and a tireless detective who hunts down those who ejaculate statistics that are ridiculously biased or fictitious. I do not agree with all of it but it is an excellent book that is stimulating much discussion. An essential reading list from george monbiot five books. Writer and investigative journalist george monbiot recommends books that have shaped him, and that are crucial reading for those wishing to navigate the current economic and environmental crises. Will low impact living also interview others george monbiot for instance. Tlio campaigns peacefully for access to the land, its resources, and the decisionmaking processes affecting them, for everyone, irrespective of age, race, or gender. A benign extravagance, a book that caused vegan advocate but nonvegan monbiot to withdraw his support for the noanimalproductsforanyoneever vegan model in favor of a system that includes. George monbiot, environmental and political activist, author and journalist about the author. Simon fairlie i heard about simon fairlie thanks to george monbiots column in the guardian on monday, i was wrong about veganism. I guess your book is full of these kinds of arguments. The inspiration for monbiots change of mind is a new book meat. The british ecojournalist, george monbiot, was an enthusiastic advocate for the vegan diet.
I am about to put down 1200 words in support of a book that starts by attacking me and often returns to this sport. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves and explores how different forms of agriculture shape our landscape and culture. George monbiot out of the wreckage a new politics for an. In spite of or maybe because of having grown up on a farm in the american midwest, i have struggled with eating meat all my life.
Simon fairlie is a great thinker and a great writer. Simon fairlie offers a wonderful and challenging corrective. Writer and investigative journalist george monbiot recommends books that have shaped him, and that are crucial reading for those wishing to navigate the current economic and environmental crises interview by david shackleton. We dont think it is, because we want to a help reduce the overall amount of meat eaten, and b help people to make a living from smallholding, which becomes a lot more difficult although not impossible without animals.
Monbiot says with what must be the most tiresome of cliches that fairlie butchers a herd of sacred cows. I heard about simon fairlie thanks to george monbiots column in the guardian on monday, i was wrong about veganism. A benign extravagance is an exploration of the difficult environmental, ethical and health issues surrounding the human consumption of animal flesh. And with george monbiot publicly changing his mind on the. Fairlie found that a vegan diet grown by means of conventional agriculture would require only 3m hectares of arable land around half the current total.
Al gore, according to reports in the us press, has gone vegan. George monbiot is always original both in the intelligence of his opinions and the depth and rigour of his research. By george monbiot, published on the guardians website 27 th november 20 he did it quietly, and the decision is the better for that. Please download pdf to see illustrations wales, george monbiot tells us in his new book feral, imports seven times as much meat as it exports the implication being that the sheep that occupy most welsh mountainsides supply us with relatively little food.
Having made a hugely significant contribution to the increasingly irrefutable, if alarming, diagnosis of the ills of early 21st century consumerist culture and its freemarket myths, george monbiot sets out now with this book to offer something more constructive, a set of proposals political, democratic, economic, environmental that might affect the. Meat, a benign extravagance by simon fairlie 9781856230551. Simon fairlie asks patrick whitefield whether permaculture has lost the plot. George monbiot out of the wreckage a new politics for. Sep 24, 2010 a new book by a leading green campaigner debunking the ethical claims made for vegetarianism has caused a stir among environmentalists. Monbiot espoused veganism as the ethical environmental choice in the early noughts. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves, and explores how. Fairlie pointed out that around half the current global meat supply causes no. A benign extravagance 2010 by simon fairlie, editor of the land magazine and himself a noted campaigner on food issues. A benign extravagance 2010, famously convinced george monbiot to publicly state he would stop being vegan although he reverted in 20. There is also considerable input to several chapters from a former appeal inspector who wishes to remain anonymous. George monbiot, environmental and political activist, author and journalist. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves, and explores how different forms of agriculture shape our landscape and.
George monbiot, environmental and political activist, author and read more. Dec 14, 2017 in this powerful and positive talk for the gaia foundation, george monbiot brings to life his new book, out of the wreckage a new politics for an age of crisis. K free excerpt available at permaculture magazine to. Gene logsdon, author of holy shit and the contrary farmer. Four years ago, i softened my position on meateating after reading simon fairlies book meat. George monbiot, environmental and political activist, author and journalist simon fairlies meat. In 2010, after reading a fascinating book by simon fairlie, a fair part of which. Certain things could be said about other aspects of his lifestyle. Anyway, in todays guardian columnist george monbiot discusses a new book, meat.
In 2010, after reading a fascinating book by simon fairlie. He was a coeditor of the ecologist magazine for four years, before joining a community farm in 1994 where he managed the cows, pigs and a working horse for ten years. He did an abrupt uturn after reading simon fairlies book, meat a benign extravagance. With this video we are proud to launch our brand new monthly series books. Al gore has gone vegan, a diet i was once sceptical about. A benign extravagance that lays into lazy arguments from all sides. In fact it delivers a net gain, as it comes from animals eating grass and crop residues that people cant consume. George monbiot, environmental and political activist, author and journalist about the author simon fairlie worked for 20 years variously as an agricultural labourer, vineworker, shepherd, fisherman, builder and stonemason before being ensnared by the computer in 1990.
I was wrong about veganism, monbiot wrote recently. A benign extravagance, a new book by simon fairlie currently only available in the u. I admit to not being previously aware of this book and will look for it. Simon fairlie on the consequences of banishing farm livestock from marginal areas. We talk here with simon fairlie, editor of the land magazine and author of meat. Jan 03, 20 the british ecojournalist, george monbiot, was an enthusiastic advocate for the vegan diet. Simon fairlie rightly comments that, with our current population, the rewilding of upland britain ii. In this unusual book he presents a persuasive argument for a new future for the planet, one in which we consciously progress from just conserving nature to actively rebuilding it. Meat eating vs vegetarian or vegan diets permaculture magazine.
Go search best sellers gift ideas new releases deals store. In the spirit of unceasing selfflagellation i think i might have been wrong about being wrong. A new book has forced me to reconsider my views on food. On 29th november george monbiot visited us here on broad street and we talked about his latest book out of the wreckage. Explore books by george monbiot with our selection at. George monbiots first book was poisoned arrows 1989, a work of investigative travel journalism exposing the transmigration programme funded by the suharto government and the world bank, and the devastating effects on both the migrants and the indigenous people of west papua. Simon was coeditor of the ecologist magazine for four years, before. Click and collect from your local waterstones or get free uk delivery on orders over. A benign extravagance is the sanest book i have read on the subject of how the human race is going to feed itself in the years ahead. By george monbiot, published in the guardian 17th december 2014. At the heart of this book, simon fairlie argues that society needs to. The environmentalist george monbiot, has argued forcefully for a switch to vegan diets.
I was wrong says former vegan diet advocate mnn mother. As monbiot notes, fairlie himself credits vegans for initiating and widening the debate and persuading. A manifesto for a new world order, was published in 2003. Simon fairlie worked for 20 years variously as an agricultural labourer, vineworker, shepherd, fisherman, builder and stonemason before being ensnared by the computer in 1990.
By george monbiot, published in the guardian on 17th december 2014. A new book by a leading green campaigner debunking the ethical claims made for vegetarianism has caused a stir among environmentalists. The ethical case against eating animal produce once seemed clear. George monbiot, uk author and environmental columnist for the guardian, has come to his senses again. In recent years two schools of thought have emerged. Simon fairlie on the sheepwrecked uplands of wales. Fairlie is a powerhouse thinker, a fire hose of ideas, and a tireless detective who hunts down those who ejaculate statistics that are ridiculously biased or.
345 1324 1307 1542 963 530 1360 920 1550 172 592 170 305 89 976 899 734 1105 921 881 604 1471 448 337 827 1477 1020 330 718 416 286 847 308 695 341 380 971 371 559 927 630 669 1286 71 127 927